Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti

Rights groups say Haiti prison riot a massacre

Rights groups say Haiti prison riot a massacre

By Joseph Guyler Delva

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti, Dec 9 (Reuters) – Haitian police killed dozens

of prisoners last week and carted out bodies in wheelbarrows during a riot

that turned into a massacre, according to a human rights group and one


The toll differs from Haitian police who say eight inmates were

killed. It also puts the spotlight on police whom U.N. officials are

already probing for the deaths in October of up to 13 supporters of ousted

President Jean-Bertrand Aristide.

Police said inmates were killed after attacking guards at the national

penitentiary in Port-au-Prince on Dec. 1, when prisoners rioted over

prolonged detention without being taken before a judge and an imminent

transfer to another prison.

One prisoner who witnessed the riot said up to 60 inmates may have

been killed by police that day.

“I saw about 15 bodies where I was, but the dead could total 60. I saw

the police transporting from the prison loads of bodies in wheelbarrows,”

Ted Nazaire, a 24-year-old prisoner released a day after the riot and who

is now in hiding, told Reuters.

The Committee for the Protection of the Haitian People’s Rights, a

rights group, said dozens of people were killed.

Another rights group, The Lawyers Committee for Individual Rights,

(CARLI), said “many more” people had been killed than police reported. The

group did not give exact figures.

“The killing of the prisoners cannot be justified and those in charge

of their security should be held responsible,” said CARLI head Renan

Hedouville. “It’s a massacre.”

The penitentiary houses about 1,070 prisoners, including supporters of

Aristide, who was forced into exile in February following a bloody

rebellion and pressure from the United States and France.

The impoverished Caribbean nation has been in turmoil since the start

of the year. Rebels took over large parts of the country before Aristide’s

departure. A U.N. peacekeeping force was sent after Aristide left to

stabilize Haiti.

Aristide supporters have complained that Haiti’s U.S.-backed interim

government, installed after Aristide’s departure and led by Haitian Prime

Minister Gerard Latortue, has rounded up and jailed hundreds of Aristide

allies without charges.

Latortue said on Wednesday that an independent probe into the deaths

would be launched.

“We have to know the truth. We don’t need to hide it, because we know

in many countries police are capable of wrongdoing,” said Latortue, who did

not confirm or deny the allegation that several dozen prisoners had been


Police showed reporters machetes, blades, knives and other weapons

that were seized during a cell search on the day of the riot. Several

police officers were hurt in the melee.

Nazaire denied police reports that some prisoners were killed by other

inmates. “The police killed the prisoners because of their opposition to

their transfer and the detention conditions,” he said.

A lawyer defending several Aristide allies, Reynold George, said those

killed were political militants who came from the pro-Aristide slums.

“There is a plan to kill several other political prisoners from

Aristide’s party,” he said.


Contact IJDH

Institute for Justice & Democracy In Haiti
867 Boylston Street, 5th Floor
Boston, MA 02116

Telephone: (857)-201-0991
General Inquiries:
Media Inquiries: