Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti

Our View: Help Haiti help itself

Appeal Democrat

Californians, especially, contributed to Haiti relief after the Jan. 12 earthquake killed an estimated 250,000 people and leveled much of the capital, Port-Au-Prince. We have our own deadly temblors, and we live knowing that one day a “Big One” will strike us.

As relief efforts have continued in Haiti, criticism has arisen that United Nations funds have not been spent properly. “The United Nations has quietly upped this year’s peacekeeping budget for earthquake-shattered Haiti to $732.4 million, with two-thirds of that amount going for the salary, perks and upkeep of its own personnel, not residents of the devastated island,” Fox News reported April 20.

Such a spending pattern is not out of the ordinary, Brett Schaefer told us; he’s the Jay Kingham Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs at the Heritage Foundation’s Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom, and author of “ConUNdrum: The Limits of the United Nations and the Search for Alternatives.”

Schaefer said that U.N. peacekeepers are not first-response teams. Such teams come from the United States, the European Union, Doctors Without Borders, the Red Cross and worldwide charities geared to immediate aid. Rather, U.N. peacekeepers come to a disaster area “to keep order and restore infrastructure to allow relief to get to the people. A lot of the costs are for those U.N. individuals — transportation, housing, etc. The majority of U.N. expenses are for staff, officers, upkeep, meetings and infrastructure.”

The real problem, he pointed out, is what the United Nations does in a country like Haiti in the long term — both before and after a disaster. Haiti long has been the most poverty-stricken country in the Western Hemisphere “despite the U.N. essentially assuming the reins of government” even before the earthquake. For decades, Haiti has been “on the borderline between stability and instability,” Schaefer said. The earthquake just tipped it into instability.

Although U.N. peacekeepers historically have been good at restoring a modicum of order in a disaster, where the United Nations fails is “what a country does after it doesn’t need the U.N. anymore — the bridge between the immediate crisis and the restoration of order.”

Schaefer pointed to a March 30 study by his Heritage colleague, Ray Walser: “Do’s and Don’ts for a Real Haiti Recovery.” It called for:

• Establishing a government “committed to service and public integrity, [which] is needed to stabilize the essential triad of public security, education, and health care delivery.”

• Congress should reduce American barriers to Haitian trade, such as sugar quotas, and other “measures that nurture the Haitian economy with incentives for entrepreneurship, investment, and market access.”

• “Accountability without paternalism. An international trust fund set up by donors with the assent of the Haitian government may improve transparency and accountability, but it is not a substitute for developing the authority, legitimacy and competence the Haitian government needs.”

We would add that America also should set a date when the U.S. government’s own involvement would end, so that Haitians really can be independent. America long has been too deeply involved in Haiti’s problems, a textbook case of counterproductive paternalism. Private aid, of course, should continue however long it’s needed.

Haiti needs free markets, property rights, rule of law, free trade, democracy — and independence.

Click HERE to see the Original Article

Contact IJDH

Institute for Justice & Democracy In Haiti
867 Boylston Street, 5th Floor
Boston, MA 02116

Telephone: (857)-201-0991
General Inquiries:
Media Inquiries: